Free shipping on orders over $100 Search Cart (0)
Free shipping on orders over $100

Authentic Grade 3 Coins

Authentic coins are in high demand. Therefore, if you see a coin you like that is marked “sold” please contact us. We can have a custom mount created specifically for you in the design of your choice on another authentic coin of your choosing.

Call to speak with one of our Treasure Specialists (800) 434-1399 
or email: onlinestore@melfisher.com if you would like more information.
Filter Down
Atocha Atocha Coins Authentic Atocha Coins Mel Fisher Mel Fisher's Treasures pendants Shipwreck Jewelry Treasure
Rare Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
Quick View
Rare Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, (You can choose any mount on our website if you would like your coin as a pendant.)
$14,000.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 4 Reales Mounted in 14K Ring, D 0.48 CT
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 4 Reales Mounted in 14K Ring, D 0.48 CT
$6,375.00 $5,535.00
Sold Out Authentic, Rare, Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Mounted in SS
Quick View
Authentic, Rare, Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Mounted in SS
$4,800.00 $4,740.00
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Rare Assayer
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Rare Assayer
$4,500.00
Rare, Fully Dated, Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
Quick View
Rare, Fully Dated, Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
$4,395.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales, Rare Mint, Mounted in 14K Gold
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales, Rare Mint, Mounted in 14K Gold
$3,650.00 $3,560.00
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales, Rare Mint
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales, Rare Mint
$3,200.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
$3,075.00 $3,000.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in SS/14K Bracelet
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in SS/14K Bracelet
$3,340.00 $2,992.00
Sold Out Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
$2,475.00
Sale Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14k/SS w/ EME
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14k/SS w/ EME
$2,500.00 $2,320.00
Sold Out Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14K/SS Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14K/SS Bezel
$2,260.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in SS Bezel
$1,900.00 $1,840.00
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
$1,600.00