USE CODE: CYBER20 or CYBER35 for purchases over $500* | SALE NOV 23-30 Search Cart (0)
USE CODE: CYBER20 or CYBER35 for purchases over $500* | SALE NOV 23-30

Authentic Grade 3 Coins

Authentic coins are in high demand. Therefore, if you see a coin you like that is marked “sold” please contact us. We can have a custom mount created specifically for you in the design of your choice on another authentic coin of your choosing.

Call to speak with one of our Treasure Specialists (800) 434-1399 
or email: onlinestore@melfisher.com if you would like more information.
Filter Down
Atocha Atocha Coins Authentic Atocha Coins Mel Fisher Mel Fisher's Treasures Shipwreck Jewelry Treasure
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales Mounted in SS/14k mount
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales Mounted in SS/14k mount
$3,015.00 $2,805.00
Sold Out Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in 14k gold
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in 14k gold
$2,650.00 $2,388.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales in 14k gold
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales in 14k gold
$2,925.00 $2,738.00
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
$1,600.00
Sold Out Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales Mounted in 14K Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales Mounted in 14K Bezel
$2,775.00 $2,625.00
Sale Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in 14K Bezel
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in 14K Bezel
$2,440.00 $2,230.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in 14k gold
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in 14k gold
$2,620.00 $2,365.00
Sold Out Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in SS mount
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in SS mount
$3,150.00
Sale Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales in SS/14K
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales in SS/14K
$2,320.00 $2,140.00
Sold Out Authentic coin from the Atocha shipwreck
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 2 Reales Mounted in 14K Bezel, Rare Mint Master
$6,375.00
Sold Out Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales mounted in 14K/SS bezel
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales mounted in 14K/SS bezel
$2,500.00
Sale Mel Fisher Authentic Atocha shipwreck Coin mounted into a ring
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 2 Reales Mounted in 14K Ring, size 14
$4,725.00 $4,087.50
Sale Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in SS, Rare Mint Master
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales Mounted in SS, Rare Mint Master
$4,800.00 $4,725.00
Sold Out Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14k gold
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14k gold
$2,380.00
Sale Mel Fisher Authentic Atocha shipwreck Coin in gold mount
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 8 Reales Mounted in 14K
$2,429.00 $2,222.00
Sale Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 4 Reales Mounted in 14K Ring, D 0.48 CT
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3 , 4 Reales Mounted in 14K Ring, D 0.48 CT
$4,975.00 $4,275.00
Rare, Fully Dated, Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
Quick View
Rare, Fully Dated, Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales
$4,395.00
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Rare Assayer
Quick View
Authentic Atocha Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales, Rare Mint Master
$4,500.00
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales, Rare Mint
Quick View
Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 4 Reales, Rare Mint
$3,200.00
Sale NEW ARRIVAL Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in SS
Quick View
NEW ARRIVAL Authentic Margarita Silver Coin, Grade 3, 8 Reales in SS
$1,900.00 $1,825.00